My Current Listings



We had narrowed our search to Middleton and were so happy to learn that our agent, Susan Stoehr, had lived there at one time herself. Susan is a warm, caring and incredibly sensitive person. She immediately made my husband and I feel at home – like we were her only client and her friend as well. Her responsiveness and professionalism were the best we’ve experienced. I truly feel we would not have found our wonderful new home without her extra efforts and guidance. She truly did go out of her way, on every level, without complaint. We highly recommend working with Susan and can’t wait to see her now that we live here!

-Nina & Gregg, Middleton



Moving from Massachusetts to Madison was stressful but was made much easier with Susan’s expert advice and help, not to mention her personal touch. She showed us houses that fit our needs and changed game plans on a dime when we became interested in different areas. The whole process was quick, efficient and seamless. We are so happy with our new house and our new town!

-Carolyn & Mark, Verona



We just bought our first home from Susan Stoehr and she helped make it fun! Susan answered all of our questions, and there were a lot of them! She was always gracious, kind, patient, and encouraging. We appreciated all the hours of work she put into this experience. We recommend Susan to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. We are very fortunate to have a great real estate agent and a new friend.

-Bryan & Sarah, Westmorland



Working with her (Susan) has been a great pleasure. Susan made buying our first home a wonderful experience. She is extremely knowledgeable and was very enthusiastic with helping us find our dream house. Susan was very patient and listened closely. She adapted well to our frequently changing wants/need, busy schedules, and our emotional ups and downs. Like any house hunt, there can be a few bumps along the way, and we were no exception. However, Susan never lost confidence and assured us we’d find the perfect home. Looking back on the “hunt”, we couldn’t be happier with the house we are in! Thanks for all your hard work Susan!

-Inthava & Brandon, Fitchburg



Susan Stoehr was wonderful to work with since we initiated our dream to move closer to Madison, and enjoy a greener/healthier lifestyle that includes more walking and biking. Susan helped us look with a discerning eye at many properties, noting the positives and challenges of the properties we were considering, so that ultimately we would be very happy with our choice. Susan worked tirelessly to promptly answer our myriad questions and kept excellent communication throughout the entire adventure. She also went above and beyond our expectations by helping us show the home we were selling in Blackhawk, assisting when we were out of town and helping to prep the home! I highly recommend Susan Stoehr.

-Lynn & Phil, Shorewood Hills



We chose Susan because she committed to us that she would do her best to move our property quickly and help us establish a realistic market price. Our property sold within 6 weeks from being listed, close to our asking price and the process was seamless from our perspective. Susan not only met but exceeded our expectations!

-Shawn & Nancy, High Point Estates



Susan Stoehr did an outstanding job as our realtor during our home buying process. Susan was always available to answer any questions that we had. I would highly recommend Susan to anyone looking to buy or sell their home!

-Jeff & Melissa, Madison



Our family’s experience with Susan was exceptional. Everyone worked as a team and we found our dream home on the first time out. Susan brought positive energy, genuine caring, integrity and joy to our experience finding a place to call home.

-The Kwon Family, Westmorland



I wish to express my deepest gratitude to Susan Stoehr for selling my home. From the moment I signed the listing contract, I encountered the highest professionalism, care, enthusiasm and passion for real estate from Susan.  She understands the importance of social media and advertising, a strong internet presence and great photography when it comes to showcasing your home. My home sold within 3 weeks for a very good price. I would will definitely recommend Susan highly to my friends and family members.

-Wendy, Madison



Susan Stoehr was patient, kind and very available to us in our search for a condo. When I’d call or send an email, she answered almost immediately. We found this most valuable. She was prepared for all appointments and her followup was excellent. I would absolutely recommend Susan’s services to friends and family – and I already have!

-Linda, Madison



If you are thinking about working with Susan, the question you should ask yourself, is not what can Susan do, but what can’t she do. Susan knows just about everything and just about everyone in Madison. We had the great pleasure to have Susan as our real estate agent. She asked all the right questions and was a great resource in helping us along the way from finding the right home to closing the deal and even to finding vendors. We highly recommend Susan, and couldn’t have done it without her!

-Maria & Strato, Madison


We couldn't have found a better agent than Susan Stoehr!  As first time home buyers it was important to us to have someone experienced who could walk us through the process and help us with any negotiations, and we found just that in Susan.  She patiently explained the entire process to us (sometimes more than once if we needed it) and was super flexible working around our crazy schedules.  She went on all of the tours with us, had an excellent list of recommended folks for inspections and financing, and really was invested in helping us find the right home.  She used our wish list but also got to know us to help us find what we wanted before we even knew what the perfect home could be!  When it came time for negotiations Susan patiently explained all of the options along with pros/cons so that we could make the right decision for ourselves.  On top of all of her credentials and excellent skills as a savvy business woman, she also is a genuinely nice person who really cares about and takes care of her clients.  We could see her commitment to us in everything that she did for us.  Thank you Susan!

-Andy & Susan B., Madison


We're so glad we had the chance to work with Susan! Being relatively new residents to the Madison area we needed a realtor we could trust to recommend the right neighborhoods based on our needs, and Susan was perfect! Being first time home buyers we had a lot of basic questions and Susan was always available to help and direct us to trusted vendors she worked with in the past. We had a great experience with Susan and would recommend them to any of our friends/family in the future!

-Jon and Sara, Madison


Susan was great. She helped with valuable suggestions on things to do that improved the marketability of my condo, and she was always timely and helpful. It only took 9 days from when the condo hit the market until I had an accepted offer.

-Gerry G, . Downtown Madison


I recommend Susan because was attentive and friendly while remaining professional. Susan played games with my daughter while we looked at homes, stuck with us when we had to postpone our search, met with us on short notice, answered questions from other family members, kept open lines of communication with me and my husband (even when we were contacting her at the same time from different locations). Susan is more than a buyer's agent, she became a friend that we will stay in contact with long after the purchase of our home!

- Justine, Madison


Moving into my brand new house right this second. Thanks to Susan Stoehr for helping me find the perfect house, walking me through the process and being so fun to hang out with. She was wonderful. (And thanks for the awesome new-home goodie bag! So thoughtful and useful! I especially love how everything is earth friendly.")

-Liz, Monona


Susan was very accommodating and efficient with setting up homes for us to view. Especially with having to come from out of town. We always felt she was working for us and not just trying to sell a house. Very knowledgeable and a joy to work with! Highly recommend.

-Cindy, Fitchburg

susanstoehrhomes 35pxBrokered by susanstoehrhomes 35px


809 Miami Pass
Madison, WI 53711

Phone: 608-212-2326

Contact Me

  1. Please type your full name.
  2. Invalid email address.
  3. Invalid Input
  4. Invalid Input

Follow Me

Susan Stoehr - Agent with The Alvarado Group   abr-logo-SMALL

Susan Stoehr reviews